Difference between revisions of "General Meeting Summary 11/18/19"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
::* Technologies map onto the EIC R&D programs | ::* Technologies map onto the EIC R&D programs | ||
::* But also some broader questions, e.g. mapping the detector performance on physics processes - here one also has synergies with the other working group | ::* But also some broader questions, e.g. mapping the detector performance on physics processes - here one also has synergies with the other working group | ||
− | |||
* Tasks for the Working Group: | * Tasks for the Working Group: | ||
::* Constrain technologies for best performance | ::* Constrain technologies for best performance | ||
::* Broader overview - integrate all detectors together in terms of performance | ::* Broader overview - integrate all detectors together in terms of performance | ||
− | |||
* Path towards achieving the goals of the Working Group include: | * Path towards achieving the goals of the Working Group include: | ||
Line 29: | Line 27: | ||
::::* R&D is currently not used to determine the overall physics and to make the best measurement | ::::* R&D is currently not used to determine the overall physics and to make the best measurement | ||
::::* barrier might be that there is currently no framework flexible enough to combine different detector technologies | ::::* barrier might be that there is currently no framework flexible enough to combine different detector technologies | ||
− | |||
* Discussion about '''possible models'''. Details might be different, but all have a set of common features: | * Discussion about '''possible models'''. Details might be different, but all have a set of common features: | ||
− | ::* '''Detector technologies - link with R&D Consortia, some integration | + | ::* '''Detector technologies''' - link with R&D Consortia, some integration |
− | ::* '''Global integration - smaller group addressing broader questions of detector performance and resolve any barriers | + | ::* '''Global integration''' - smaller group addressing broader questions of detector performance and resolve any barriers |
− | ::* '''Simulation - support, global framework | + | ::* '''Simulation''' - support, global framework |
− | |||
* Available documentation to guide the effort - it may be beneficial to remind of the examples documented and how one would advance those with new ideas and identify key questions | * Available documentation to guide the effort - it may be beneficial to remind of the examples documented and how one would advance those with new ideas and identify key questions |
Revision as of 09:46, 19 November 2019
ACTION ITEMS
- Summary of this meeting (Tanja)
- Make a diagram of the organizational structure and lines of communication (Peter)
- Starting from the SC list, make a list of names for the detector groups (all)
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
- Goal of the Working Group: Survey of detector technologies for a Yellow Report, e.g. Detector Technologies for CLIC (arXiv:1905.02520)
- Technologies map onto the EIC R&D programs
- But also some broader questions, e.g. mapping the detector performance on physics processes - here one also has synergies with the other working group
- Tasks for the Working Group:
- Constrain technologies for best performance
- Broader overview - integrate all detectors together in terms of performance
- Path towards achieving the goals of the Working Group include:
- Detector technologies
- start with list of detectors and make a list of people who can contribute, e.g. 4-5 per detector
- subconveners can be identified from the list, one subconvener per detector
- Monte Carlo expertise essential for each detector group as it is input to guide technologies
- Resolve barriers towards combining pieces and making the global physics measurement
- current R&D is targeted and assumes basic performance parameters
- R&D is currently not used to determine the overall physics and to make the best measurement
- barrier might be that there is currently no framework flexible enough to combine different detector technologies
- Discussion about possible models. Details might be different, but all have a set of common features:
- Detector technologies - link with R&D Consortia, some integration
- Global integration - smaller group addressing broader questions of detector performance and resolve any barriers
- Simulation - support, global framework
- Available documentation to guide the effort - it may be beneficial to remind of the examples documented and how one would advance those with new ideas and identify key questions
- Detector R&D Handbook
- White Paper
- In general it is good to keep in mind to look at panorama of detectors
MIT MEETING AGENDA FEEDBACK
- Perhaps beneficial to have discussion with all working group conveners
- boundaries between working groups not yet clearly defined
- what should be plenary and what parallel?
- discussion of role of simulations group
- Update on simulations
- need core simulation - learning curve for university students/postdocs to contribute is too steep
NEXT MEETINGS:
MON 25 NOV AT 12:30PM (ET)
MON 2 DEC AT 12:00PM - 1:30PM (ET)